I’ve read several articles recently about the British Columbia mother and her 20 month-old daughter who were kicked off a city bus 14 blocks from their destination because her toddler was – ready for it – crying.
Yes, you read that right. Apparently, after five minutes of being on the bus, and her daughter crying loudly (despite her mother’s desperate attempts to soothe her), the driver told her that she had to learn to control her daughter and stopped the bus and sent them off.
I was shocked.
If that wasn’t bad enough, the flurry of internet attention that she’s garnered has been massive – and a lot of it has been commenters calling her an unfit mother, lazy, an attention-seeking princess, a hippie who knows no boundaries, and a single mom who should go to college to afford a car.
Seriously.
Now, I know firsthand how difficult it is to drive while a child is screaming in the backseat. I’m sure most of you moms out there have been there at least once. It’s not easy and I can understand how distracting it would be for the driver of the bus.
However, kicking her off – not even at another bus stop, as I understand it – is simply unimaginable.
I think the worst part for me, though, is the comments from people. I’m amazed at how free people are at sharing their very strong opinions on all kinds of things on the internet, when they’re shielded by the vastness of cyberspace. I’m peeved that one commenter, who signed as “Old Guy” wrote “spare the rod, spoil the child.” Like, seriously? Did children of thirty or fifty years ago not have any temper tantrums ever? Were they all perfectly angelic children? Did whipping kids turn them into better adults as a result?
What do you think of all this? Am I the only person (who does, in fact, discipline my children and isn’t a total pushover, but still has children who meltdown on occasion) who feels for this poor mother from BC?









Geez, I wouldn't last a minute on that bus. My 2-year-old boy twin has recently learned the way of the public tantrum. Four kids and he's the only to lose his shiznit, but, boy oh boy, he makes up for all the others. And, I really haven't been able to do much with the tantrums aside from averting my gaze and mentally willing myself to my happy place.
ReplyDeletePublic transportation...people should lighten up. Kids are gonna cry sometimes, people are gonna cough, sneeze, fart, what have you...should they all be kicked off?
Now, taking a baby to a movie theater? That one gets up my craw. I just returned from seeing "Avatar" (for the second time, i love it so) where someone had a newborn crying off and on. I'm talking itty bitty couldn't have been more than a few weeks old. Now that bothered me, more so for the baby being subjected to the very loud movie and strangers coughing in an enclosed theater. Oof, that really bothers me. A baby crying on a bus, no. But, don't bring a baby to the movies....ever, ever, ever.
Do you have a discrete spot where I can store my soapbox? I'd hate for the kids to trip over it.
I do sympathize with the driver because a crying baby can be extremely distracting. Some cries are worse than others--some are just so piercing they make it hard for you to concentrate. If he has a busload of people who depend on him to drive well, then that becomes an issue.
ReplyDeleteThat said, it does sound like the mother was at least TRYING to calm the child, and it sounds like other passengers wanted to let her stay. That being the case, I'd like to think the bus driver would be willing to let her stay on a mere 5 minutes longer.
I don't think you can keep your child under control absolutely all the time. I've seen plenty of children who are wonderfully behaved the vast majority of the time have a meltdown when they are tired or coming down with a cold or flu bug.
I remember going to a grocery store one time when Hana was about 11 months old and the store ended up being way busier than I expected it to be. We picked up everything we needed then went to the cash and found the lines were all long. After 5 minutes of waiting Hana started to get tired and fussy. Another 5 minutes later and she was screaming like mad. I considered abandoning the cartful of stuff, but I thought that would be kind of rude to just leave it there and besides, I would still have to pick up the groceries again anyway. What got me through the situation is that several woman passed by who smiled nicely and said things like, "Been there!" or "Oh, I remember that age!" Now I try to do the same thing when I see a mom in the same situation.
If you have a child who does not have meltdowns... you are dead. I've heard there will be no more meltdowns in heaven. For real.
ReplyDeleteRevelation 21:4 "He will wipe every tear from their eyes. There will be no more death or mourning or crying or pain, for the old order of things has passed away."
I was SHOCKED by this. kids cry. If she was trying to controll the situation I am discusted that HE (of course it was a MAN) asked her to get off the bus. I hope she talks alot a bout the disgrace of the PUBLIC system.
ReplyDeleteI woman driver would never have done that I have to say.
I hope that mother is able to ignore the idiotic comments. It's weird how the internet brings out the weirdo in some people. It's a disgrace that she was kicked off the bus.
ReplyDeleteI think one of the sorriest commentaries on our modern world is how little patience people have with the sounds of children anymore. We manage to tune out traffic, construction, sirens, and advertising 24/7 with no problem, but are finding babies increasingly intolerable.
ReplyDeleteI have to admit i did not hear of this story..but come on..people need to toughen up..many things can go wrong each day and when driving a bus you need to adapt and carry on..I know I drove a big school bus while in college..you cant let a scream or a cry or a knapsack hitting your head stop you from doing your job...
ReplyDeleteI totally feel sorry for her! I get rather embarrassed when my son cries in public, I knowit cant be helped. Like his teeth might be playing him up so he cried in pain!
ReplyDeleteThis Woman may of been embarrassed enough but the driver had to add to that and kick her of the bus!
And now the woman has the internet chucking silly things at her like how she should have a car!
That's just cruel. I think that bus driver should be smacked or kicked in the balls for what he did. Wow... well that's men for ya xD
ReplyDeleteOh, my goodness! I hope the driver has been disciplined.
ReplyDeleteIt's amazing, though, how many people seem to expect children to behave perfectly at every moment of the day. How many of us mothers find us self-censoring our lives, as it were, because of these people? I know parents who tag-team going to church because they fear the disapproving glares when their kids act up. (How the kids are supposed to learn how to behave there, I don't know.) I myself don't give blood any more because the blood center hours are such that I have to bring the kids along, and I've gotten tired of snarky comments (from Red Cross workers, not other donors!) when I bring them.
Wow...I didn't hear about this, but now I want to read the story. That is complete CRAP that the driver was even able to do that..and that she got off! If I was her, I would've sat my happy bum right in my seat and not moved...that is sexism, if you ask me, and I wonder if a father with his son would've been treated the same way...or if people's comments would have read something like - boys will be boys!
ReplyDelete~WM
Wow...I missed this one.
ReplyDeleteEvery kid has a bad day now and then - no matter how great the parents. I can't believe somebody would kick a crying kid off a bus.
I think the bus driver should be kicked for this...
ReplyDeletei've learned to tune the tantrums out! lol
ReplyDeleteThat's sad.
ReplyDeleteI've nannied enough children to know that there are just times when NOTHING is gonna soothe them.
I just love how outsiders think they know what's best. Really? Let's lock you in a room with a colicky baby and see you work your 'magic'....idiots...
This does not sound good for the bus company! I would much rather see some of those rude yelling teenagers thrown off! We have all been there. Had a day when no matter what you do you can't keep your baby quiet:(
ReplyDeleteI didn't know of this story, but wow. That poor woman. I always wonder if people who criticize others' parenting are parents themselves. My guess is no.
ReplyDeleteBecause I wasn't there and don't know the details of the situations other than what's been reported, I can only say this much... that bus driver would have had to PUT me and my crying child off the bus!!! What if I was on the way to the hospital or doctor's office b/c she was ill?
ReplyDeleteThat is ridiculous! Thank God I don't ride a bus in BC cuz me and my hooligans would get booted pretty quickly. And bet your sweet ass I'd be raising hell about it, too.
ReplyDeleteThose people making acccusations and judgements obviously don't have children. If they did have children they would know that children have melt downs and there's no way to control it. AND you don't have to be an uneducated hippie to have a child like that. I have one, and I also have a very passive quiet child. 2 very different personalities , both with the same 2 parents! Imagine that. There's many a time I knew people on airplanes wanted me thrown off because of my child! But you can't control these things!!
ReplyDelete